Trilogy at Power Ranch vs Encanterra: Two Trilogy Communities, Two Club Models

Trilogy at Power Ranch in Gilbert is an age-restricted, gated community built around a public golf course. Encanterra in Queen Creek is a gated Shea Homes Trilogy resort community where only select neighborhoods are 55+ and the golf is private. Same brand name, very different setups.

Trilogy at Power Ranch vs Encanterra at a glance

Trilogy at Power RanchEncanterra
LocationSoutheast Gilbert, ZIP 85298Combs and Gantzel roads, Queen Creek, ZIP 85140 (Pinal County)
Age rulesAge-restricted communityPartly 55+; select Trilogy neighborhoods are age-restricted, others are all ages
GatedYesYes, gated entry
GolfPower Ranch Golf Club: 18 holes, par 71, Dick Bailey design, public tee timesPrivate 18-hole championship course designed by Tom Lehman
Clubs and amenitiesCommunity clubhouse, two pools and a spa, fitness center, tennis, pickleball, bocceLa Casa and The Algarve clubhouses, restaurants, pools, spa, fitness, pickleball, studios
New or resaleEstablished community; homes change hands as resalesShea lists new homes; resales also available

I'm Terry Day, REALTOR®, DeLex Realty. Here is how I separate these two for buyers comparing them.

Fully age-restricted vs partly 55+

The Trilogy at Power Ranch community website describes it as an age-restricted, gated, private resort community. It shares a name with the Power Ranch area of Gilbert, but the Trilogy community has its own association, website and amenities.

Shea Homes describes Encanterra as a partial 55+ community: select 55+ Trilogy neighborhoods sit alongside homes for all ages. Shea's page does not map which neighborhoods are which, so I check the specific neighborhood for every home before a buyer gets attached. The exact age rules are in each neighborhood's CC&Rs.

How golf and club membership work

Power Ranch Golf Club says it welcomes public tee times year-round, so playing the course does not depend on owning in the community. The golf club's site also lists a restaurant and bar, Slate Bistro, with a patio overlooking the course.

Encanterra Country Club is private. Its club materials say that all Encanterra owners are social members, that owners can upgrade to a golf membership, and that non-resident memberships are not currently available. Membership categories, fees and policies change, so I send buyers to the club for current terms. I never assume a home on a fairway comes with playing privileges.

Clubhouses and amenities

Trilogy at Power Ranch lists a community clubhouse with a fitness center, two swimming pools and a spa, sports courts for tennis, pickleball and bocce, and clubs and activities for members.

Encanterra centers on La Casa, about 60,000 square feet of indoor and outdoor space with several dining venues, including Palma Kitchen + Tap, which the club describes as members only. The Algarve is a second, smaller club with a resort pool and pickleball. Shea also lists a Culinary Studio, an Art Studio, a spa and hundreds of homeowner-led clubs.

New construction or resale

Power Ranch is an established community, so buying there means a resale, and I look closely at air conditioning, water heaters, roofs and any past changes that needed association approval.

At Encanterra, Shea lists new homes and quick move-in homes, and resales trade as well, which lets a buyer compare the two. A builder's sales team represents the builder. If you want your own agent, tell the sales center before your first visit so the registration terms are clear.

Location and city

Trilogy at Power Ranch is in southeast Gilbert, inside the Town of Gilbert. Encanterra is at Combs and Gantzel roads in Pinal County. It opened as part of the San Tan Valley area, and the Town of Queen Creek annexed it in 2019. The annexation was approved that October, and a court challenge by residents did not stop it. Property listings may still say San Tan Valley, so I confirm the city and jurisdiction for each address.

Association layers

Before an offer I read the CC&Rs, the age rules, the rental rules and the reserve study. I confirm which associations apply to the specific home, including any master-level association, and I get current assessments and transfer fees in writing from the association.

Pick Trilogy at Power Ranch if... / Pick Encanterra if...

Pick Trilogy at Power Ranch if you want an age-restricted gated community throughout, a golf course open to public tee times, and a resale purchase in Gilbert.

Pick Encanterra if you want a private Tom Lehman course, the La Casa and Algarve clubs, the option of a new Shea home, and you are comfortable confirming whether a given home sits in a 55+ or all-ages neighborhood.

What I notice on tours

Many buyers assume both are entirely 55+ because of the Trilogy name. At Encanterra, that is the first thing I sort out. After that, the choice usually comes down to public golf and a Gilbert address versus a private club and the new-home option.

Questions buyers ask

Is Encanterra a 55+ community?

Partly. Shea describes select 55+ Trilogy neighborhoods alongside homes for all ages. Age rules are in the CC&Rs.

Is Trilogy at Power Ranch gated?

Yes. Its community website describes an age-restricted, gated, private resort community.

Can the public play the golf?

Power Ranch Golf Club welcomes public tee times. Encanterra's course is private, with membership tied to Encanterra owners.

Can I buy a new home in either?

Shea lists new homes at Encanterra. Power Ranch is an established community where homes are resales.

Is Encanterra in San Tan Valley or Queen Creek?

It sits in Pinal County and was annexed into the Town of Queen Creek in 2019, though some listings still say San Tan Valley.

Community guides: Trilogy at Power Ranch homes for sale | Encanterra homes for sale

Terry Day, REALTOR®, DeLex Realty, can walk you through both communities and check the age rules, club terms and association documents for any home you like.

More 55+ guides: Arizona 55+ Living hub.

Sources: Trilogy at Power Ranch community website (mytpr.com), Power Ranch Golf Club (powerranchgolfclub.com), Shea Homes Encanterra page (sheahomes.com), Encanterra Country Club (mytrilogylife.com/encanterra), KTAR and Queen Creek Independent reporting on the 2019 annexation.

Browse the 55+ community finder Call Terry: 602-483-4665

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!