If you're used to a smaller New Jersey lot, a Phoenix townhome and a detached house with a courtyard may offer almost exactly the outdoor space you want. The deciding question is who can make changes to that space and who has to take care of the building around it.
Start with the patio, not the shared wall
Say your ideal Arizona evening involves a grill, a small table and a dog slipping out the back door with you. A listing photo of a private-looking patio doesn't tell you whether you can change the surface, add shade or install the gate you'd like. Tell me how you intend to use it, and we can ask about each activity while we're still choosing which homes to tour.
On the townhome tour, follow the route a worker would take to reach the patio. Would they need to pass through your living room? Is there a gate onto shared space? On the detached-home tour, look at how close the neighboring windows are and where equipment sits. Write down the usable seating area with the grill and the door swing accounted for. A detached wall on the parcel map doesn't add elbow room at dinner.
Find the answer to the roof question in writing
For both properties, ask for the declaration, the current association budget if there is one, and the pages assigning responsibility for the roof, exterior walls and any shared features. A building's shape alone won't tell you its ownership structure. Arizona has separate resale disclosure statutes for condominiums (A.R.S. 33-1260) and planned communities (A.R.S. 33-1806). Which one applies depends on the property.
Ask a specific question about a hypothetical leak above the kitchen. Who do you contact, who inspects, who authorizes opening the roof, and who handles damage inside? Give the association's answer and documents to your insurer to discuss coverage and deductibles. Don't settle for "the HOA covers the exterior" if you still don't know whom to call when there is water inside.
Look at planned work, too. Ask for the budget and any reserve information, and ask whether an assessment has been approved or discussed. Compare what the association actually arranges with what you would arrange yourself at the detached house. A dues figure by itself doesn't tell you whether the ownership routine suits you.
Try a weekday arrival, including the extra car
Back in New Jersey you may have a routine for street parking, deliveries and visitors. Rehearse it in both Arizona homes. Start from the space a guest could actually use, walk to the front door carrying a bag and notice any gate, step or long turn. Check the rules for overnight visitors, vehicles in driveways and any permit required. Ask for a written answer if the parking plan depends on an exception.
Inside, try the room closest to the shared wall at a time you'd use it. Walk upstairs if there is a second floor. Pay attention to the distance between parking and the room where you would unload groceries. In the detached home, try the same routine with the garage door open and closed. Neither label promises that the everyday trip will be easier.
Put one real project on both shopping lists
Pick something you'd want to change in your first year, perhaps a shade cover or an outlet on the patio. For each address, sketch the proposed location and ask which local and association approvals apply. If a change is essential, get those answers before you commit. If it is optional, decide whether you would still enjoy the property exactly as it stands.
I compare recent townhome sales within the same development separately from detached sales with similar outdoor space. Then I put the photos, ownership responsibilities and project answers beside the sales figures. That makes it easier to see whether you're choosing extra control over your yard, an easier maintenance routine or simply the floor plan you liked best.
New Jersey to Arizona housing questions
Is a Phoenix townhome always a condominium? Ask for the legal description and governing documents for the actual address. Have your agent and title team identify the ownership form, then use the applicable documents to check what you own and maintain.
Can I lock up and leave for visits back east? Ask what needs attention during an absence, including patio plants, leaks, HVAC monitoring and packages. Confirm any association procedures and your insurance arrangements for the period you'll be away.
What if the detached house also has an HOA? Read its documents with the same questions you'd bring to a townhome. Find out what you must maintain, what needs permission and which common expenses are shared before you compare dues.
Which one feels more like my New Jersey neighborhood? Tell me what you miss when you're away from it. If it's chatting outside, look at the entries and sitting areas. If it's privacy at dinner, compare sightlines from the patio table. Those details survive a move better than a housing label.
Written by Terry Day, REALTOR®, DeLex Realty. Planning a move? Call 602-483-4665.